Deep HIARCS 14 vs. Stockfish 060714 64

Designed for posting all types of tournaments and Games (e.g. Man vs. Machine, Computer vs. Computer and basement matches.)

Moderators: Harvey Williamson, Watchman

Forum rules
This textbox is used to restore diagrams posted with the [d] tag before the upgrade.
Post Reply
User avatar
Hasimir
Member
Posts: 62
Joined: Sun Jun 29, 2014 1:24 pm
Location: Australia
Contact:

Deep HIARCS 14 vs. Stockfish 060714 64

Post by Hasimir »

I ran these throughout the day in order to satisfy my own curiosity and, I'll admit, in part hoping to deflate some of the intense Stockfish fandom I've encountered elsewhere. The result, however, was that I was rather more impressed by Stockfish than I'd expected.

These are engine games run in Mac-HCE 1.7 (Deep HIARCS 14 with full downloaded opening books) on a quad-core i7 MBP with 8Gb RAM and running OS X 10.9. There are 12 games total, the first two used the single core HIARCS 14, the rest took advantage of the multic-cores and multi-threading. Each pair of rounds used different time controls. The Stockfish engine version is 060714 64, which is the current sources from github and compiled immediately prior to the tests (a generic 64-bit architecture build).

The first two games were between HIARCS 14 and Stockfish and I had honestly expected Stockfish to wipe the floor with that version of HIARCS. So I was pleasantly surprised to see each side win one match. They both won as black, which I find to be typical of engines, which tend to favour aggressive games and thus take advantage of moving first.

[Event "Engine match"]
[Site "?"]
[Date "2014.07.06"]
[Round "1.1"]
[White "HIARCS 14 WCSC"]
[Black "Stockfish 060714 64"]
[Result "1-0"]
[ECO "A23"]
[EventDate "2014.07.06"]
[OpeningBook "Began on local books, manually switched to Online Tournament as it began."]
[TimeControl "m10000"]

1.c4 e5 { [%eval 8,22] } 2.Nc3 Nf6 { [%eval 8,22] } 3.g3 c6 { [%eval 0,21] }
4.Nf3 d5 { [%eval -8,21] } 5.d4 { [%eval -21,17] } 5...exd4 { [%eval -5,20] }
6.Qxd4 { [%eval -14,17] } 6...Be6 { [%eval -6,22] } 7.Ng5 { [%eval -26,16] }
7...Nbd7 { [%eval -18,21] } 8.cxd5 { [%eval -33,16] } 8...Bc5
{ [%eval 0,22] } 9.Qh4 { [%eval -36,16] } 9...cxd5 { [%eval -19,22] } 10.Bg2
{ [%eval -39,15] } 10...O-O { [%eval -18,21] } 11.O-O { [%eval -42,16] }
11...Rc8 { [%eval -10,22] } 12.Nxd5 { [%eval -13,15] } 12...Bxd5
{ [%eval -1,24] } 13.Bxd5 { [%eval -13,15] } 13...h6 { [%eval -1,25] }
14.Bxf7+ { [%eval -15,17] } 14...Rxf7 { [%eval -13,24] } 15.Nxf7
{ [%eval -10,17] } 15...Kxf7 { [%eval 0,22] } 16.Qc4+ { [%eval -16,17] }
16...Kf8 { [%eval 0,23] } 17.Qb3 { [%eval -25,17] } 17...b6 { [%eval 0,23] }
18.Be3 { [%eval -7,17] } 18...Qe7 { [%eval -6,24] } 19.Bxc5 { [%eval -2,17] }
19...Rxc5 { [%eval 0,23] } 20.Rfe1 { [%eval 3,17] } 20...g5 { [%eval 0,22] }
21.Rad1 { [%eval 17,16] } 21...Kg7 { [%eval 0,23] } 22.Qa3 { [%eval 36,18] }
22...a5 { [%eval 12,23] } 23.Rc1 { [%eval 35,18] } 23...g4 { [%eval 7,22] }
24.f3 { [%eval 43,17] } 24...Qe6 { [%eval 0,25] } 25.Rxc5 { [%eval 40,17] }
25...Nxc5 { [%eval 0,28] } 26.fxg4 { [%eval 28,17] } 26...Nxg4
{ [%eval 0,26] } 27.Qf3 { [%eval 29,18] } 27...Ne3 { [%eval 0,26] } 28.Rc1
{ [%eval 29,18] } 28...Kg6 { [%eval 13,24] } 29.Qf4 { [%eval 34,17] }
29...Ng4 { [%eval 0,27] } 30.Qc4 { [%eval 33,18] } 30...Qe3+ { [%eval 0,25] }
31.Kh1 { [%eval 32,19] } 31...Nf6 { [%eval 0,25] } 32.Rf1 { [%eval 29,17] }
32...Qd2 { [%eval 0,27] } 33.Qb5 { [%eval 31,18] } 33...Qd5+ { [%eval 0,28] }
34.Kg1 { [%eval 20,19] } 34...Qd4+ { [%eval 0,27] } 35.Kg2 { [%eval 20,19] }
35...Qe4+ { [%eval 0,29] } 36.Rf3 { [%eval 20,19] } 36...Nfd7
{ [%eval 0,27] } 37.b3 { [%eval 35,18] } 37...Nf6 { [%eval 0,28] } 38.Qc4
{ [%eval 40,18] } 38...Qxc4 { [%eval 0,29] } 39.bxc4 { [%eval 17,20] }
39...Nfe4 { [%eval 0,29] } 40.Rf4 { [%eval 32,22] } 40...a4 { [%eval 0,28] }
41.h4 { [%eval 28,21] } 41...Nc3 { [%eval 24,26] } 42.Rd4 { [%eval 35,21] }
42...Nxa2 { [%eval 16,28] } 43.Rd6+ { [%eval 56,21] } 43...Kf7
{ [%eval 44,29] } 44.Rxb6 { [%eval 53,22] } 44...Nc1 { [%eval 48,26] }
45.Rxh6 { [%eval 86,21] } 45...a3 { [%eval 0,30] } 46.Rh7+ { [%eval 96,22] }
46...Kg6 { [%eval 0,31] } 47.Ra7 { [%eval 138,22] } 47...a2 { [%eval 0,32] }
48.Kh2 { [%eval 219,21] } 48...Kf6 { [%eval 35,28] } 49.g4 { [%eval 268,19] }
49...Nd7 { [%eval 204,23] } 50.g5+ { [%eval 313,19] } 50...Kf5
{ [%eval 177,22] } 51.e4+ { [%eval 337,19] } 51...Kxe4 { [%eval 319,25] }
52.g6 { [%eval 360,21] } 52...Nf6 { [%eval 337,27] } 53.g7 { [%eval 360,20] }
53...Ng4+ { [%eval 337,27] } 54.Kh3 { [%eval 414,21] } 54...Nh6
{ [%eval 506,25] } 55.c5 { [%eval 430,20] } 55...Kd5 { [%eval 674,29] } 56.c6
{ [%eval 478,21] } 56...Kxc6 { [%eval 723,29] } 57.Ra6+ { [%eval 500,20] }
57...Kc5 { [%eval 736,29] } 58.Rxh6 { [%eval 517,15] } 1-0

[Event "Engine match"]
[Site "?"]
[Date "2014.07.06"]
[Round "1.2"]
[White "Stockfish 060714 64"]
[Black "HIARCS 14 WCSC"]
[Result "1-0"]
[ECO "A40"]
[EventDate "2014.07.06"]
[OpeningBook "Online: Tournament"]
[TimeControl "m10000"]

1.d4 { [%eval 17,21] } 1...c6 2.Bf4 { [%eval 40,21] } 2...Qb6 3.b3
{ [%eval 34,22] } 3...d5 4.e3 { [%eval 35,21] } 4...Bf5 5.Bd3
{ [%eval 38,22] } 5...Bxd3 6.Qxd3 { [%eval 34,23] } 6...Nf6 7.Nf3
{ [%eval 36,22] } 7...e6 8.O-O { [%eval 32,22] } 8...Nbd7 9.c4
{ [%eval 30,22] } 9...Qa6 10.Nbd2 { [%eval 36,22] } 10...Be7
{ [%eval 29,16] } 11.e4 { [%eval 36,21] } 11...dxe4 { [%eval 27,16] } 12.Nxe4
{ [%eval 32,22] } 12...Nxe4 { [%eval 25,17] } 13.Qxe4 { [%eval 31,22] }
13...O-O { [%eval 26,16] } 14.Rfe1 { [%eval 34,22] } 14...Rfd8
{ [%eval 30,16] } 15.Qe3 { [%eval 29,21] } 15...Qa5 { [%eval 24,16] } 16.Qd3
{ [%eval 26,21] } 16...Nf8 { [%eval 17,17] } 17.Bd2 { [%eval 26,19] }
17...Qa3 { [%eval 15,17] } 18.Bc3 { [%eval 25,21] } 18...Ng6
{ [%eval 11,16] } 19.g3 { [%eval 21,22] } 19...Bf6 { [%eval -35,15] } 20.h4
{ [%eval 10,21] } 20...a5 { [%eval -28,15] } 21.Qc2 { [%eval 0,21] } 21...h6
22.Rad1 { [%eval 20,20] } 22...b5 { [%eval -7,16] } 23.c5 { [%eval 215,22] }
23...a4 { [%eval 0,19] } 24.b4 { [%eval 383,25] } 24...Rd5 { [%eval 407,18] }
25.Re3 { [%eval 515,24] } 25...Rad8 { [%eval 541,19] } 26.Be1
{ [%eval 536,24] } 26...Qxe3 { [%eval 558,18] } 27.fxe3 { [%eval 551,23] }
1-0

As you can see the PGN includes each engine's evaluations of the strength of its moves or not. The time control was set to average at around 10 seconds per move.

When these games were done I essentially repeated them except with Deep HIARCS 14 instead. The outcome of round 2.1 came as a little bit of a surprise; a draw, but the outcome of 2.2 was a little more of a shock with Stockfish winning. That said, Stockfish was White, so it wasn't entirely out of place for a strong and aggressive engine.

[Event "Engine match"]
[Site "?"]
[Date "2014.07.06"]
[Round "2.1"]
[White "Deep HIARCS 14 WCSC"]
[Black "Stockfish 060714 64"]
[Result "1/2-1/2"]
[ECO "C65"]
[EventDate "2014.07.06"]
[OpeningBook "Began on local books, manually switched to Online Tournament as it began."]
[TimeControl "m10000"]

1.e4 e5 { [%eval 22,21] } 2.Nf3 Nc6 { [%eval 22,21] } 3.Bb5 Nf6
{ [%eval 15,21] } 4.d3 d6 { [%eval 11,21] } 5.c3 a6 { [%eval -4,23] } 6.Ba4
Be7 { [%eval 3,22] } 7.O-O O-O { [%eval 1,22] } 8.h3 b5 { [%eval 7,20] }
9.Bc2 d5 { [%eval 12,22] } 10.Nbd2 Be6 { [%eval 16,21] } 11.d4 exd4
{ [%eval 44,21] } 12.e5 d3 { [%eval 47,23] } 13.Bxd3 { [%eval 15,18] }
13...Nd7 { [%eval 29,24] } 14.Re1 { [%eval 42,19] } 14...Nc5
{ [%eval 35,24] } 15.Bb1 { [%eval 45,20] } 15...Qd7 { [%eval 43,20] } 16.Nb3
{ [%eval 53,19] } 16...b4 { [%eval 42,22] } 17.Nxc5 { [%eval 86,19] }
17...Bxc5 { [%eval 55,20] } 18.Qd3 { [%eval 70,20] } 18...g6
{ [%eval 20,19] } 19.Bg5 { [%eval 69,18] } 19...bxc3 { [%eval 29,20] }
20.bxc3 { [%eval 76,18] } 20...Rab8 { [%eval 14,23] } 21.Qd2
{ [%eval 79,18] } 21...Rb6 { [%eval 43,23] } 22.Bf6 { [%eval 77,18] }
22...Rfb8 { [%eval 42,23] } 23.Bd3 { [%eval 73,17] } 23...Qc8
{ [%eval 56,22] } 24.Qh6 { [%eval 78,17] } 24...Qf8 { [%eval 65,23] } 25.Qh4
{ [%eval 78,18] } 25...Rb2 { [%eval 59,22] } 26.Rf1 { [%eval 78,17] } 26...h6
{ [%eval 61,21] } 27.Qf4 { [%eval 67,17] } 27...Be7 { [%eval 78,21] } 28.Bxa6
{ [%eval 111,17] } 28...Ra8 { [%eval 84,22] } 29.Bxe7 { [%eval 96,17] }
29...Nxe7 { [%eval 79,23] } 30.Qc1 { [%eval 110,19] } 30...Rbb8
{ [%eval 82,23] } 31.Bd3 { [%eval 117,18] } 31...Rb7 { [%eval 95,23] } 32.Qd2
{ [%eval 124,18] } 32...Rba7 { [%eval 64,22] } 33.Rfb1 { [%eval 124,19] }
33...c5 { [%eval 63,24] } 34.Qe3 { [%eval 102,18] } 34...c4 { [%eval 74,23] }
35.Bc2 { [%eval 109,20] } 35...Rxa2 { [%eval 93,25] } 36.Rxa2
{ [%eval 111,22] } 36...Rxa2 { [%eval 87,25] } 37.Nd4 { [%eval 112,20] }
37...Ra6 { [%eval 87,25] } 38.Qg3 { [%eval 110,18] } 38...Kg7
{ [%eval 87,22] } 39.Qf4 { [%eval 110,18] } 39...Bd7 { [%eval 68,24] } 40.Kh2
{ [%eval 91,19] } 40...Qd8 { [%eval 62,22] } 41.Re1 { [%eval 92,18] }
41...Bc8 { [%eval 68,23] } 42.Re3 { [%eval 95,18] } 42...Bd7
{ [%eval 82,23] } 43.h4 { [%eval 93,17] } 43...h5 { [%eval 64,22] } 44.Re1
{ [%eval 76,20] } 44...Kg8 { [%eval 58,21] } 45.Kg1 { [%eval 78,18] }
45...Qa8 { [%eval 68,24] } 46.Re3 { [%eval 78,18] } 46...Qc8
{ [%eval 87,23] } 47.Rf3 { [%eval 96,21] } 47...Nf5 { [%eval 127,24] }
48.Bxf5 { [%eval 92,20] } 48...Bxf5 { [%eval 110,26] } 49.Kh2
{ [%eval 86,21] } 49...Be6 { [%eval 110,27] } 50.Qf6 { [%eval 86,21] }
50...Qe8 { [%eval 74,29] } 51.Nf5 { [%eval 114,22] } 51...Bxf5
{ [%eval 60,30] } 52.Qxa6 { [%eval 115,22] } 52...Qxe5+ { [%eval 62,32] }
53.g3 { [%eval 118,25] } 53...Qe4 { [%eval 62,34] } 54.Rf4 { [%eval 112,27] }
54...Qe6 { [%eval 62,32] } 55.Qxe6 { [%eval 122,26] } 55...fxe6
{ [%eval 51,33] } 56.Rd4 { [%eval 95,29] } 56...Bd3 { [%eval 74,33] } 57.f3
{ [%eval 75,30] } 57...Kf7 { [%eval 0,41] } 58.g4 { [%eval 55,25] } 58...Ke7
{ [%eval 0,38] } 59.Kg3 { [%eval 52,28] } 59...Kd6 { [%eval 0,36] } 60.f4
{ [%eval 4,29] } 60...Kc5 { [%eval 0,37] } 61.g5 { [%eval 55,29] } 61...Kb5
{ [%eval 0,42] } 62.Kf2 { [%eval 55,32] } 62...Ka4 { [%eval 0,44] } 63.Ke3
{ [%eval 55,30] } 63...Kb5 { [%eval 0,47] } 64.Kd2 { [%eval 55,28] } 64...Kc6
{ [%eval 0,48] } 65.Ke3 Kb5 { [%eval 0,81] } 66.Kd2 Kc5 { [%eval 0,44] }
67.Kc1 { [%eval 0,28] } 1/2-1/2

[Event "Engine match"]
[Site "?"]
[Date "2014.07.06"]
[Round "2.2"]
[White "Stockfish 060714 64"]
[Black "Deep HIARCS 14 WCSC"]
[Result "1-0"]
[ECO "A80"]
[EventDate "2014.07.06"]
[OpeningBook "Online: Tournament"]
[TimeControl "m10000"]

1.d4 { [%eval 17,21] } 1...f5 2.Nf3 { [%eval 51,22] } 2...e6 3.e3
{ [%eval 29,23] } 3...Nf6 4.c4 { [%eval 33,21] } 4...b6 5.Be2
{ [%eval 27,23] } 5...Bb7 6.O-O { [%eval 27,24] } 6...Bd6 7.b3
{ [%eval 38,21] } 7...O-O 8.Bb2 { [%eval 34,21] } 8...f4 { [%eval 32,18] }
9.exf4 { [%eval 63,22] } 9...Bxf4 { [%eval 14,17] } 10.Nc3 { [%eval 63,23] }
10...c5 { [%eval 13,17] } 11.d5 { [%eval 73,21] } 11...Na6 { [%eval 10,16] }
12.g3 { [%eval 94,22] } 12...Bh6 { [%eval 18,17] } 13.Ne5 { [%eval 96,23] }
13...d6 { [%eval 7,19] } 14.Ng4 { [%eval 104,23] } 14...Nxg4
{ [%eval 28,19] } 15.Bxg4 { [%eval 107,23] } 15...e5 { [%eval 38,19] } 16.f4
{ [%eval 113,22] } 16...exf4 { [%eval 70,18] } 17.Be6+ { [%eval 167,22] }
17...Kh8 { [%eval 71,18] } 18.Ne4 { [%eval 155,24] } 18...f3
{ [%eval 99,19] } 19.Rxf3 { [%eval 190,24] } 19...Nc7 { [%eval 78,20] }
20.Bf5 { [%eval 196,25] } 20...Qe7 { [%eval 75,19] } 21.Qf1
{ [%eval 222,25] } 21...Bc8 { [%eval 217,19] } 22.Re1 { [%eval 229,27] }
22...Bxf5 { [%eval 213,19] } 23.Rxf5 { [%eval 230,27] } 23...b5
{ [%eval 249,21] } 24.Nxd6 { [%eval 303,24] } 24...Be3+ { [%eval 312,21] }
25.Kh1 { [%eval 395,24] } 25...bxc4 { [%eval 334,19] } 26.Nf7+
{ [%eval 458,27] } 26...Kg8 { [%eval 549,21] } 27.Qxc4 { [%eval 464,29] }
27...Rxf7 { [%eval 544,21] } 28.d6 { [%eval 468,29] } 28...Qe6
{ [%eval 560,23] } 29.Rxf7 { [%eval 474,28] } 29...Qxf7 { [%eval 568,23] }
30.dxc7 { [%eval 486,26] } 30...Qxc4 { [%eval 569,23] } 31.bxc4
{ [%eval 486,26] } 31...Rc8 { [%eval 568,23] } 32.Rxe3 { [%eval 491,25] }
1-0

The third pair of games made things a little more interesting again. I changed the time controls to 40 moves in 5 minutes. The first of these games, round 3.1, ended up being the longest, in number of moves, of the entire group of games. It also resulted in a draw 90 moves in.

[Event "Engine match"]
[Site "?"]
[Date "2014.07.06"]
[Round "3.1"]
[White "Deep HIARCS 14 WCSC"]
[Black "Stockfish 060714 64"]
[Result "1/2-1/2"]
[ECO "C47"]
[EventDate "2014.07.06"]
[OpeningBook "Local books."]
[TimeControl "300@40"]

1.e4 e5 { [%eval 31,20] } 2.Nc3 Nc6 { [%eval 18,20] } 3.Nf3 Nf6
{ [%eval 10,21] } 4.d4 exd4 { [%eval -11,21] } 5.Nxd4 Bb4 { [%eval -9,22] }
6.Nxc6 bxc6 { [%eval -7,22] } 7.Bd3 d5 { [%eval -8,22] } 8.exd5 O-O
{ [%eval -4,21] } 9.dxc6 Re8+ { [%eval 0,23] } 10.Be3 { [%eval 13,18] }
10...Ng4 { [%eval 0,24] } 11.Qf3 { [%eval 19,19] } 11...Qh4
{ [%eval -20,20] } 12.O-O-O { [%eval 15,19] } 12...Nxe3 { [%eval -18,19] }
13.fxe3 { [%eval 21,18] } 13...Bxc3 { [%eval -29,21] } 14.bxc3
{ [%eval 18,18] } 14...Qe7 { [%eval -30,22] } 15.Rhf1 { [%eval 37,17] }
15...Be6 { [%eval -4,20] } 16.a4 { [%eval 15,17] } 16...Rad8
{ [%eval -39,20] } 17.Qe4 { [%eval 0,18] } 17...g6 { [%eval -16,21] } 18.Qe5
{ [%eval 0,18] } 18...f5 { [%eval -51,21] } 19.Kd2 { [%eval 17,16] } 19...Rd6
{ [%eval -13,22] } 20.Ke2 { [%eval 0,18] } 20...Rxc6 { [%eval -26,23] }
21.Qd4 { [%eval 10,17] } 21...Rc5 { [%eval -13,24] } 22.Rfe1 { [%eval 0,18] }
22...Rd8 { [%eval -28,22] } 23.Qb4 { [%eval -24,20] } 23...a5
{ [%eval -42,22] } 24.Qf4 { [%eval -38,19] } 24...Rxc3 { [%eval -47,23] }
25.Kf1 { [%eval -39,18] } 25...Qc5 { [%eval -42,22] } 26.Kg1
{ [%eval -39,17] } 26...Re8 { [%eval -42,21] } 27.h4 { [%eval -18,16] }
27...Bc4 { [%eval -41,22] } 28.h5 { [%eval -24,17] } 28...Bxd3
{ [%eval -36,22] } 29.cxd3 { [%eval -7,16] } 29...Kg7 { [%eval -42,22] }
30.Qf3 { [%eval -19,16] } 30...Qb4 { [%eval -78,20] } 31.Qd5
{ [%eval -37,17] } 31...Qxa4 { [%eval -106,20] } 32.e4 { [%eval -37,18] }
32...fxe4 { [%eval -107,22] } 33.dxe4 { [%eval -57,18] } 33...Qb4
{ [%eval -107,22] } 34.Rd4 { [%eval -58,18] } 34...Qc5 { [%eval -89,23] }
35.hxg6 { [%eval -57,18] } 35...hxg6 { [%eval -102,24] } 36.Qd7+ Re7
{ [%eval -121,23] } 37.Qd8 { [%eval -57,18] } 37...Rg3 { [%eval -126,19] }
38.e5 { [%eval -42,18] } 38...Rg5 { [%eval -117,22] } 39.e6
{ [%eval -44,18] } 39...c6 { [%eval -120,24] } 40.Qd6 { [%eval -49,19] }
40...Qxd6 { [%eval -110,23] } 41.Rxd6 { [%eval -50,18] } 41...c5
{ [%eval -90,25] } 42.Ra6 { [%eval -62,20] } 42...c4 { [%eval -114,26] }
43.Rc6 { [%eval -61,20] } 43...Kf6 { [%eval -114,27] } 44.Re3
{ [%eval -67,21] } 44...c3 { [%eval -116,21] } 45.Kf2 c2 { [%eval -114,25] }
46.Rxc2 { [%eval -64,20] } 46...Rxe6 { [%eval -114,26] } 47.Rf3+
{ [%eval -64,22] } 47...Rf5 { [%eval -121,28] } 48.Rc4 { [%eval -66,24] }
48...Ra6 { [%eval -120,31] } 49.Ra4 { [%eval -52,23] } 49...Ke6
{ [%eval -120,30] } 50.Rxf5 { [%eval -62,22] } 50...Kxf5 { [%eval -126,31] }
51.Kf3 { [%eval -63,25] } 51...Ra8 { [%eval -124,32] } 52.Kf2
{ [%eval -63,29] } 52...Ra7 { [%eval -124,34] } 53.Kf3 { [%eval -63,30] }
53...Ra6 { [%eval -117,33] } 54.Kf2 { [%eval -63,28] } 54...Ra8
{ [%eval -118,33] } 55.Kf3 { [%eval -63,29] } 55...Ke5 { [%eval -118,34] }
56.Ke3 { [%eval -63,29] } 56...Ke6 { [%eval -118,31] } 57.Ke4
{ [%eval -63,29] } 57...Ra6 { [%eval -118,33] } 58.Ke3 { [%eval -63,30] }
58...Ra7 { [%eval -118,36] } 59.Ke2 { [%eval -63,29] } 59...Kf6
{ [%eval -118,33] } 60.Kf1 { [%eval -64,26] } 60...Kg5 { [%eval -126,32] }
61.Kg1 { [%eval -64,29] } 61...Ra6 { [%eval -126,34] } 62.g3
{ [%eval -64,32] } 62...Kf5 { [%eval -130,37] } 63.Kf1 { [%eval -64,32] }
63...Ke5 { [%eval -130,38] } 64.Ke2 { [%eval -64,31] } 64...Kd5
{ [%eval -130,36] } 65.Kd3 { [%eval -64,27] } 65...Kc5 { [%eval -126,35] }
66.Kc2 { [%eval -64,30] } 66...Kd6 { [%eval -126,35] } 67.Kd3
{ [%eval -64,30] } 67...Kc7 { [%eval -126,37] } 68.Kc4 { [%eval -64,29] }
68...Kc6 { [%eval -126,34] } 69.Kc3 { [%eval -64,30] } 69...Kd7
{ [%eval -129,33] } 70.Kd4 { [%eval -64,30] } 70...Ke6 { [%eval -129,35] }
71.Ke3 { [%eval -64,31] } 71...Ra8 { [%eval -129,35] } 72.Ke2
{ [%eval -64,31] } 72...Kf5 { [%eval -129,33] } 73.Kf1 { [%eval -64,33] }
73...Ra6 { [%eval -129,34] } 74.Kf2 { [%eval -64,32] } 74...Ke5
{ [%eval -130,36] } 75.Ke1 { [%eval -64,32] } 75...Kd6 { [%eval -136,31] }
76.Kd2 { [%eval -64,31] } 76...Kc7 { [%eval -146,31] } 77.Kc3
{ [%eval -64,30] } 77...Rc6+ { [%eval -148,31] } 78.Kb3 { [%eval -64,34] }
78...Rc5 { [%eval -149,32] } 79.Rg4 { [%eval -64,34] } 79...g5
{ [%eval -136,35] } 80.Rd4 { [%eval -64,32] } 80...Kc6 { [%eval -136,36] }
81.Ka4 { [%eval -64,31] } 81...Rf5 { [%eval -136,37] } 82.Rg4
{ [%eval -65,32] } 82...Rb5 { [%eval -136,39] } 83.Rc4+ { [%eval -64,35] }
83...Kb6 { [%eval -136,43] } 84.Ka3 { [%eval -64,31] } 84...Rc5
{ [%eval -136,42] } 85.Rg4 { [%eval -65,31] } 85...Rd5 { [%eval -136,43] }
86.Kb3 { [%eval -65,32] } 86...Kb5 { [%eval -136,46] } 87.Ka3
{ [%eval -65,31] } 87...Rc5 { [%eval -136,45] } 88.Ka2 { [%eval -65,32] }
88...Re5 { [%eval -136,44] } 89.Ka3 { [%eval -65,34] } 89...Kb6
{ [%eval -136,48] } 90.Kb3 { [%eval -65,31] } 90...Kc7 { [%eval -136,41] }
1/2-1/2

The next game, round 3.2, finally proved that there are some realms in which HIARCS retains an edge. Mainly that HIARCS appears to handle different time controls better than Stockfish. In fact, the victory in 3.2 is due almost entirely to the clock running out on Stockfish.

[Event "Engine match"]
[Site "?"]
[Date "2014.07.06"]
[Round "3.2"]
[White "Stockfish 060714 64"]
[Black "Deep HIARCS 14 WCSC"]
[Result "0-1"]
[ECO "B94"]
[EventDate "2014.07.06"]
[OpeningBook "Local books."]
[TimeControl "300@40"]

1.e4 { [%eval 24,20] } 1...c5 2.Nf3 { [%eval 37,21] } 2...d6 3.d4
{ [%eval 26,20] } 3...cxd4 4.Nxd4 { [%eval 18,20] } 4...Nf6 5.Nc3
{ [%eval 27,20] } 5...a6 6.Bg5 { [%eval 20,21] } 6...Nbd7 7.Bc4
{ [%eval 31,21] } 7...e6 8.O-O { [%eval 34,17] } 8...Qa5 9.Be3
{ [%eval 20,20] } 9...b5 10.Bb3 { [%eval 20,21] } 10...Bb7 11.a3
{ [%eval 18,22] } 11...Qc7 12.f3 { [%eval 23,21] } 12...Nc5 13.Ba2
{ [%eval 17,22] } 13...Be7 14.Qe1 { [%eval 14,22] } 14...O-O 15.Qg3
{ [%eval 4,22] } 15...Rac8 { [%eval 13,17] } 16.Rad1 { [%eval 10,21] }
16...Rfe8 17.Rfe1 { [%eval 10,21] } 17...Nh5 { [%eval 4,21] } 18.Qh3
{ [%eval 16,21] } 18...Nf6 { [%eval 2,19] } 19.Re2 { [%eval 16,20] }
19...Rcd8 { [%eval 21,19] } 20.Qg3 { [%eval 16,23] } 20...Rc8
{ [%eval 24,19] } 21.Red2 { [%eval 16,21] } 21...Nh5 { [%eval 14,20] } 22.Qf2
{ [%eval 15,21] } 22...Nf6 { [%eval 17,20] } 23.g4 { [%eval 15,21] } 23...Na4
{ [%eval -9,17] } 24.Nxa4 { [%eval 0,20] } 24...bxa4 { [%eval -10,18] }
25.Ne2 { [%eval 0,21] } 25...Nd7 { [%eval -3,17] } 26.g5 { [%eval 0,20] }
26...Ne5 { [%eval -3,16] } 27.Nc3 { [%eval 0,20] } 27...Bc6
{ [%eval -26,17] } 28.Rd4 { [%eval 0,21] } 28...Bb5 { [%eval -23,16] }
29.Nxb5 { [%eval 0,21] } 29...axb5 { [%eval -34,15] } 30.c3 { [%eval 6,22] }
30...Qb7 { [%eval -24,18] } 31.R4d2 { [%eval 0,21] } 31...Nc4
{ [%eval -42,17] } 32.Bxc4 { [%eval 0,24] } 32...bxc4 { [%eval -21,19] }
33.h4 { [%eval 0,24] } 33...Ra8 { [%eval -31,18] } 34.Bf4 { [%eval 11,21] }
34...e5 { [%eval -43,17] } 35.Be3 { [%eval 6,24] } 35...Rf8
{ [%eval -47,19] } 36.h5 { [%eval 0,21] } 36...f5 { [%eval -57,20] } 37.Qg2
{ [%eval 0,23] } 37...Rab8 { [%eval -56,18] } 38.g6 { [%eval 0,23] } 38...h6
{ [%eval -82,18] } 39.Re2 { [%eval -8,23] } 39...Rf6 $138 { [%eval -84,18] }
0-1

Having seen that result I decided to push that luck by trying the two engines in a contest where they each had five minutes to do everything. The result was that Stockfish won both rounds. So it appeared that HIARCS had better time management, but only within reason.

[Event "Engine match"]
[Site "?"]
[Date "2014.07.06"]
[Round "4.1"]
[White "Deep HIARCS 14 WCSC"]
[Black "Stockfish 060714 64"]
[Result "0-1"]
[ECO "D37"]
[EventDate "2014.07.06"]
[OpeningBook "Local books."]
[TimeControl "300"]

1.d4 Nf6 { [%eval 18,20] } 2.c4 e6 { [%eval 27,19] } 3.Nf3 d5
{ [%eval 26,19] } 4.Nc3 Be7 { [%eval 21,21] } 5.g3 O-O { [%eval -3,20] }
6.Bg2 dxc4 { [%eval -11,21] } 7.Ne5 Nc6 { [%eval -3,23] } 8.Bxc6 bxc6
{ [%eval 0,23] } 9.Nxc6 Qd7 { [%eval 0,23] } 10.Qa4 { [%eval -8,19] }
10...Bd6 { [%eval 2,21] } 11.Qxc4 { [%eval -7,19] } 11...a5 { [%eval 13,21] }
12.Ne5 { [%eval 8,18] } 12...Qe8 { [%eval 26,23] } 13.O-O { [%eval 13,18] }
13...Ba6 { [%eval 24,24] } 14.Qc6 { [%eval 14,17] } 14...Bxe5
{ [%eval 30,24] } 15.Qxe8 { [%eval 17,18] } 15...Rfxe8 { [%eval 31,25] }
16.dxe5 { [%eval 15,19] } 16...Nd5 { [%eval 25,25] } 17.Re1 { [%eval 14,20] }
17...Nxc3 { [%eval 34,25] } 18.bxc3 { [%eval 9,19] } 18...Red8
{ [%eval 27,25] } 19.a4 { [%eval 6,19] } 19...h6 { [%eval 24,25] } 20.Be3
{ [%eval 6,20] } 20...Rab8 { [%eval 0,24] } 21.Bd4 { [%eval 3,20] } 21...Rb2
{ [%eval 0,25] } 22.e3 { [%eval 4,22] } 22...Rdb8 { [%eval 0,23] } 23.c4
{ [%eval 14,22] } 23...Rc2 { [%eval 6,25] } 24.c5 { [%eval 14,22] } 24...Rb4
{ [%eval 6,24] } 25.Reb1 { [%eval 18,20] } 25...Rxb1+ { [%eval 2,24] }
26.Rxb1 { [%eval 19,18] } 26...Kf8 { [%eval 2,25] } 27.Rb8+ { [%eval 17,21] }
27...Ke7 { [%eval 0,26] } 28.g4 { [%eval 15,22] } 28...Bc4 { [%eval 0,26] }
29.f3 { [%eval 28,19] } 29...Bd5 { [%eval 0,27] } 30.e4 { [%eval 42,21] }
30...Bc6 { [%eval 0,27] } 31.Rc8 { [%eval 43,21] } 31...Kd7 { [%eval 0,26] }
32.Rg8 { [%eval 14,21] } 32...g5 { [%eval -47,22] } 33.Rh8 { [%eval 7,20] }
33...Bxa4 { [%eval -83,22] } 34.Ra8 { [%eval -14,18] } 34...Rc4
{ [%eval -92,22] } 35.Be3 { [%eval -25,21] } 35...Bd1 { [%eval -98,23] }
36.Kf2 { [%eval -30,21] } 36...a4 { [%eval -94,23] } 37.Ra6
{ [%eval -41,20] } 37...c6 { [%eval -94,24] } 38.Ra7+ { [%eval -41,19] }
38...Kc8 { [%eval -105,23] } 39.Ra6 { [%eval -45,19] } 39...Kc7
{ [%eval -121,22] } 40.Ra7+ { [%eval -42,20] } 40...Kb8 { [%eval -103,24] }
41.Ra6 { [%eval -46,22] } 41...Rc2+ { [%eval -129,22] } 42.Kg3
{ [%eval -53,23] } 42...Rc3 { [%eval -136,24] } 43.Kf2 { [%eval -53,23] }
43...a3 { [%eval -138,26] } 44.Rxc6 { [%eval -64,19] } 44...Rc2+
{ [%eval -192,22] } 45.Kg3 { [%eval -64,19] } 45...Be2 { [%eval -186,25] }
46.Rb6+ { [%eval -65,19] } 46...Kc7 { [%eval -186,27] } 47.Rb3
{ [%eval -64,21] } 47...a2 { [%eval -211,23] } 48.Ra3 { [%eval -62,21] }
48...Kc6 { [%eval -211,27] } 49.Bd4 { [%eval -62,20] } 49...Bc4
{ [%eval -194,23] } 50.Ra5 { [%eval -87,21] } 50...Bf1 { [%eval -225,26] }
51.Bf2 { [%eval -111,22] } 51...Rd2 { [%eval -227,28] } 52.Ra4 Bc4
{ [%eval -303,23] } 53.Be1 { [%eval -228,20] } 53...Rd1 { [%eval -323,23] }
54.Bc3 { [%eval -228,19] } 54...Kxc5 { [%eval -353,22] } 55.Ra5+
{ [%eval -242,19] } 55...Kb6 { [%eval -359,23] } 56.Ra4 { [%eval -274,21] }
56...Rg1+ { [%eval -382,22] } 57.Kf2 { [%eval -282,20] } 57...Rc1
{ [%eval -394,23] } 58.Rxc4 { [%eval -284,21] } 58...Rc2+ { [%eval -498,21] }
59.Kg3 { [%eval -466,26] } 59...Rxc3 { [%eval -507,26] } 60.Ra4
{ [%eval -476,21] } 60...Rc2 { [%eval -519,26] } 61.h4 { [%eval -660,24] }
61...Kb5 { [%eval -602,25] } 62.Ra7 { [%eval -660,22] } 62...Kb4
{ [%eval -624,25] } 63.Kh3 { [%eval -807,22] } 63...Kb3 { [%eval -856,23] }
64.Rb7+ { [%eval -827,20] } 64...Kc3 { [%eval -961,24] } 65.Ra7
{ [%eval -948,24] } 65...Kb2 { [%eval -1049,24] } 66.Rb7+ { [%eval -958,22] }
66...Kc1 { [%eval -1340,24] } 67.Ra7 { [%eval -982,21] } 67...Kb1
{ [%eval -1562,25] } 68.Rb7+ { [%eval -1186,22] } 68...Rb2
{ [%eval -1702,27] } 69.Ra7 { [%eval -1195,22] } 69...a1=Q
{ [%eval -4625,30] } 0-1

[Event "Engine match"]
[Site "?"]
[Date "2014.07.06"]
[Round "4.2"]
[White "Stockfish 060714 64"]
[Black "Deep HIARCS 14 WCSC"]
[Result "1-0"]
[ECO "B31"]
[EventDate "2014.07.06"]
[OpeningBook "Local books."]
[TimeControl "300"]

1.e4 { [%eval 24,20] } 1...c5 2.Nf3 { [%eval 37,21] } 2...Nc6 3.Bb5
{ [%eval 33,21] } 3...g6 4.O-O { [%eval 26,18] } 4...Bg7 5.Nc3
{ [%eval 31,21] } 5...d6 6.e5 { [%eval 23,20] } 6...dxe5 7.Bxc6+
{ [%eval 16,20] } 7...bxc6 8.Re1 { [%eval 6,21] } 8...f6 9.d3
{ [%eval 7,22] } 9...Nh6 10.Be3 { [%eval 7,21] } 10...Qa5 11.Ne4
{ [%eval 12,20] } 11...c4 12.d4 { [%eval 8,20] } 12...Nf5 { [%eval 71,16] }
13.dxe5 { [%eval 6,19] } 13...fxe5 { [%eval 55,17] } 14.Qe2 { [%eval 27,20] }
14...Nxe3 { [%eval 51,18] } 15.Qxe3 { [%eval 24,21] } 15...O-O
{ [%eval 48,18] } 16.Qe2 { [%eval 15,21] } 16...Be6 { [%eval 47,17] } 17.b3
{ [%eval 18,21] } 17...Bd5 { [%eval 53,17] } 18.Nfd2 { [%eval 21,22] }
18...cxb3 { [%eval 53,18] } 19.axb3 { [%eval 21,23] } 19...Qb6
{ [%eval 51,18] } 20.Nc4 { [%eval 27,21] } 20...Qb5 { [%eval 51,19] } 21.f3
{ [%eval 33,20] } 21...Rf4 { [%eval 50,18] } 22.Ncd2 { [%eval 39,20] }
22...Qxe2 { [%eval 54,19] } 23.Rxe2 { [%eval 39,21] } 23...a5 24.Ra4
{ [%eval 45,20] } 24...Rff8 { [%eval 54,18] } 25.Re1 { [%eval 50,22] }
25...Rfd8 { [%eval 56,18] } 26.Rea1 { [%eval 69,21] } 26...Bh6
{ [%eval 68,18] } 27.Kf2 { [%eval 74,23] } 27...Rab8 { [%eval 80,18] }
28.Rxa5 { [%eval 80,20] } 28...Rb4 { [%eval 82,17] } 29.Ra8
{ [%eval 112,20] } 29...Rxa8 { [%eval 83,18] } 30.Rxa8+ { [%eval 112,20] }
30...Kf7 { [%eval 103,19] } 31.Ke2 { [%eval 120,21] } 31...Bf4
{ [%eval 128,19] } 32.g3 { [%eval 129,21] } 32...Bxd2 { [%eval 146,21] }
33.Nxd2 { [%eval 137,22] } 33...Be6 { [%eval 153,20] } 34.Ra6
{ [%eval 151,23] } 34...Bd7 { [%eval 143,20] } 35.Ke3 { [%eval 157,22] }
35...Rb5 { [%eval 140,20] } 36.Ne4 { [%eval 155,23] } 36...h6
{ [%eval 144,19] } 37.h4 { [%eval 154,25] } 37...Ke8 { [%eval 167,21] }
38.Nf2 { [%eval 177,23] } 38...Kf8 { [%eval 196,22] } 39.Nd3
{ [%eval 216,22] } 39...g5 { [%eval 196,20] } 40.hxg5 { [%eval 221,23] }
40...hxg5 { [%eval 235,22] } 41.g4 { [%eval 247,22] } 41...Be8
{ [%eval 280,22] } 42.Ra8 { [%eval 260,22] } 42...e6 { [%eval 282,21] } 43.b4
{ [%eval 281,22] } 43...Ke7 { [%eval 289,23] } 44.c3 { [%eval 297,23] }
44...Rd5 { [%eval 289,22] } 45.Nc5 { [%eval 313,23] } 45...Kf7
{ [%eval 357,21] } 46.Ra7+ { [%eval 319,23] } 46...Kg6 { [%eval 345,20] }
47.Ne4 { [%eval 328,24] } 47...Rd8 { [%eval 350,20] } 48.Ra5
{ [%eval 343,21] } 48...Rd5 { [%eval 365,21] } 49.c4 { [%eval 350,21] }
49...Rd1 { [%eval 365,19] } 50.Rxe5 { [%eval 356,21] } 50...Rb1
{ [%eval 389,19] } 51.Rxe6+ { [%eval 405,20] } 1-0

Then I dropped the über short games in favour of settings which were, if anything, closest to those used during the World Chess Software Championships. Not quite the same, but close enough for my purposes. That is each side was given an average of 15 seconds per move.

This turned things back in favour of HIARCS, but not quite far enough. The result was a pair of draws.

[Event "Engine match"]
[Site "?"]
[Date "2014.07.06"]
[Round "5.1"]
[White "Stockfish 060714 64"]
[Black "Deep HIARCS 14 WCSC"]
[Result "1/2-1/2"]
[ECO "E41"]
[EventDate "2014.07.06"]
[OpeningBook "Local books."]
[OutOfBook "From move 12."]
[TimeControl "m15000"]

1.d4 { [%eval 20,22] } 1...Nf6 2.c4 { [%eval 34,21] } 2...e6 3.Nc3
{ [%eval 22,22] } 3...Bb4 4.e3 { [%eval 18,22] } 4...c5 5.Nf3
{ [%eval 19,22] } 5...O-O 6.Be2 { [%eval 18,23] } 6...d5 7.O-O
{ [%eval 27,21] } 7...Nc6 8.a3 { [%eval 26,21] } 8...Bxc3 9.bxc3
{ [%eval 12,24] } 9...Qc7 10.cxd5 { [%eval 30,20] } 10...exd5 11.dxc5
{ [%eval 33,23] } 11...Na5 12.Bb2 { [%eval 31,22] } 12...Nc4
{ [%eval 38,19] } 13.Bxc4 { [%eval 29,23] } 13...dxc4 { [%eval 32,18] }
14.Qd6 { [%eval 28,23] } 14...Qa5 { [%eval 11,19] } 15.a4 { [%eval 26,25] }
15...Rd8 { [%eval 15,19] } 16.Qf4 { [%eval 27,24] } 16...Qxc5
{ [%eval 23,19] } 17.Nd4 { [%eval 21,25] } 17...Qa5 { [%eval 6,17] } 18.Rfc1
{ [%eval 29,23] } 18...Bd7 { [%eval 17,19] } 19.e4 { [%eval 28,24] } 19...Re8
{ [%eval 7,19] } 20.f3 { [%eval 32,24] } 20...Nh5 { [%eval 35,20] } 21.Qh4
{ [%eval 43,24] } 21...Rad8 { [%eval 35,20] } 22.Ba3 { [%eval 43,24] }
22...Qe5 { [%eval 42,20] } 23.Rcb1 { [%eval 43,24] } 23...Bc6
{ [%eval 35,20] } 24.a5 { [%eval 41,25] } 24...a6 { [%eval 53,21] } 25.Qf2
{ [%eval 39,25] } 25...Nf4 { [%eval 37,20] } 26.Bc1 { [%eval 39,28] }
26...Nd3 { [%eval 42,21] } 27.Qg3 { [%eval 67,26] } 27...Bb5
{ [%eval 40,21] } 28.Nxb5 { [%eval 68,27] } 28...axb5 { [%eval 0,21] }
29.Qxe5 { [%eval 86,25] } 29...Rxe5 { [%eval 67,25] } 30.Be3
{ [%eval 85,26] } 30...b4 { [%eval 68,22] } 31.cxb4 { [%eval 100,24] }
31...f5 { [%eval 69,21] } 32.b5 { [%eval 113,25] } 32...c3 { [%eval 68,20] }
33.a6 { [%eval 113,26] } 33...bxa6 { [%eval 94,19] } 34.bxa6
{ [%eval 120,27] } 34...fxe4 { [%eval 89,20] } 35.a7 { [%eval 179,24] }
35...Ree8 { [%eval 89,20] } 36.fxe4 { [%eval 199,26] } 36...c2
{ [%eval 78,22] } 37.Rb5 { [%eval 191,27] } 37...Ra8 { [%eval 81,22] } 38.Rb7
{ [%eval 179,29] } 38...Rec8 { [%eval 75,21] } 39.Kf1 { [%eval 182,29] }
39...c1=Q+ { [%eval 113,21] } 40.Bxc1 { [%eval 189,29] } 40...Nxc1
{ [%eval 122,22] } 41.Ra3 { [%eval 189,27] } 41...h5 { [%eval 133,23] }
42.Rf3 { [%eval 186,27] } 42...Re8 { [%eval 133,21] } 43.g3
{ [%eval 204,23] } 43...Kh7 { [%eval 165,22] } 44.Rc3 { [%eval 273,26] }
44...Na2 { [%eval 165,24] } 45.Ra3 { [%eval 272,27] } 45...Nc1
{ [%eval 165,25] } 46.Rc7 { [%eval 266,28] } 46...Rxe4 { [%eval 165,27] }
47.Rxc1 { [%eval 279,28] } 47...Re7 { [%eval 165,29] } 48.Rca1
{ [%eval 268,30] } 48...g6 { [%eval 165,28] } 49.h4 { [%eval 310,28] }
49...Ree8 { [%eval 166,29] } 50.Re1 { [%eval 310,34] } 50...Rf8+
{ [%eval 166,34] } 51.Kg2 { [%eval 309,34] } 51...Rf7 { [%eval 166,35] }
52.Rea1 { [%eval 309,35] } 52...Re7 { [%eval 166,34] } 53.Ra6
{ [%eval 309,36] } 53...Kg7 { [%eval 166,33] } 54.g4 { [%eval 309,36] }
54...hxg4 { [%eval 166,24] } 55.Kg3 { [%eval 309,36] } 55...Re4
{ [%eval 166,28] } 56.R1a4 { [%eval 309,33] } 56...Re3+ { [%eval 166,29] }
57.Kxg4 { [%eval 309,35] } 57...Ree8 { [%eval 166,28] } 58.Kg5
{ [%eval 309,34] } 58...Re5+ { [%eval 166,28] } 59.Kf4 { [%eval 309,36] }
59...Re7 { [%eval 166,28] } 60.R4a5 { [%eval 309,36] } 60...Re1
{ [%eval 166,27] } 61.Rg5 { [%eval 309,34] } 61...Kf7 { [%eval 166,26] }
62.Rb5 { [%eval 309,35] } 62...Re7 { [%eval 166,28] } 63.Rba5
{ [%eval 309,36] } 63...Re1 { [%eval 166,28] } 64.Ra1 { [%eval 309,35] }
64...Re7 { [%eval 166,30] } 65.R1a2 { [%eval 309,36] } 65...Rb7
{ [%eval 166,28] } 66.R2a5 { [%eval 309,32] } 66...Rb1 { [%eval 166,27] }
67.Ra3 { [%eval 309,33] } 67...Rb7 { [%eval 166,28] } 68.R3a4
{ [%eval 309,34] } 1/2-1/2

[Event "Engine match"]
[Site "?"]
[Date "2014.07.06"]
[Round "5.2"]
[White "Deep HIARCS 14 WCSC"]
[Black "Stockfish 060714 64"]
[Result "1/2-1/2"]
[ECO "C67"]
[EventDate "2014.07.06"]
[OpeningBook "Local books."]
[OutOfBook "From move 21."]
[TimeControl "m15000"]

1.e4 e5 { [%eval 22,21] } 2.Nf3 Nc6 { [%eval 23,22] } 3.Bb5 Nf6
{ [%eval 12,21] } 4.O-O Nxe4 { [%eval 16,23] } 5.d4 Be7 { [%eval 21,24] }
6.Qe2 Nd6 { [%eval 23,24] } 7.Bxc6 bxc6 { [%eval 36,27] } 8.dxe5 Nf5
{ [%eval 30,26] } 9.c4 O-O { [%eval 27,23] } 10.Nc3 d6 { [%eval 21,22] }
11.Bf4 g5 { [%eval 42,19] } 12.Be3 f6 { [%eval 43,20] } 13.exd6 cxd6
{ [%eval 41,22] } 14.Nd4 Bd7 { [%eval 51,22] } 15.Qd3 Qc8 { [%eval 58,20] }
16.Rae1 Rf7 { [%eval 47,22] } 17.f4 g4 { [%eval 41,23] } 18.Bf2 Nxd4
{ [%eval 45,24] } 19.Qxd4 f5 { [%eval 51,25] } 20.Re2 Qb7 { [%eval 40,25] }
21.Rd1 { [%eval 67,19] } 21...Bf8 { [%eval 41,25] } 22.Rde1 { [%eval 65,19] }
22...a5 { [%eval 40,24] } 23.Bh4 { [%eval 62,19] } 23...a4 { [%eval 40,24] }
24.Be7 { [%eval 71,19] } 24...Bg7 { [%eval 37,25] } 25.Qd3 { [%eval 67,20] }
25...d5 { [%eval 49,24] } 26.cxd5 { [%eval 67,19] } 26...cxd5
{ [%eval 46,24] } 27.Bc5 { [%eval 68,19] } 27...Bc6 { [%eval 50,23] } 28.Bd4
{ [%eval 74,19] } 28...Qa6 { [%eval 61,22] } 29.Qd2 { [%eval 64,19] }
29...Rd8 { [%eval 53,23] } 30.Re6 { [%eval 78,18] } 30...Qc4
{ [%eval 58,23] } 31.Rd1 { [%eval 70,19] } 31...Bxd4+ { [%eval 65,24] }
32.Qxd4 { [%eval 69,18] } 32...Qxd4+ { [%eval 64,26] } 33.Rxd4
{ [%eval 83,19] } 33...Rc7 { [%eval 64,27] } 34.Re5 { [%eval 83,20] }
34...Rb8 { [%eval 75,24] } 35.Nd1 { [%eval 63,22] } 35...Rf7
{ [%eval 75,24] } 36.Re2 { [%eval 63,22] } 36...Bb5 { [%eval 62,26] } 37.Red2
{ [%eval 64,24] } 37...Bc4 { [%eval 57,27] } 38.Nc3 { [%eval 63,24] }
38...Rfb7 { [%eval 58,26] } 39.Nxa4 { [%eval 63,25] } 39...Bxa2
{ [%eval 56,28] } 40.Nc3 { [%eval 63,26] } 40...Bb3 { [%eval 56,28] } 41.Nxd5
{ [%eval 63,24] } 41...Kg7 { [%eval 57,26] } 42.Re2 { [%eval 63,21] }
42...Bxd5 { [%eval 49,27] } 43.Rxd5 { [%eval 53,21] } 43...Rf7
{ [%eval 49,28] } 44.Kf2 { [%eval 44,21] } 44...Rb4 { [%eval 49,28] } 45.Kg3
{ [%eval 48,23] } 45...Kg6 { [%eval 32,25] } 46.Rd6+ { [%eval 47,23] }
46...Kh5 { [%eval 25,28] } 47.Rd3 { [%eval 28,22] } 47...Rf6
{ [%eval 37,27] } 48.Rd7 { [%eval 22,24] } 48...h6 { [%eval 9,28] } 49.Rd5
{ [%eval 14,23] } 49...Rb3+ { [%eval 12,30] } 50.Kf2 { [%eval 14,21] }
50...Kg6 { [%eval 12,33] } 51.Rdd2 { [%eval 11,24] } 51...Rb4
{ [%eval 3,26] } 52.Kg3 { [%eval 14,27] } 52...Rfb6 { [%eval 1,30] } 53.Rc2
{ [%eval 7,27] } 53...Kh5 { [%eval 1,31] } 54.Rc5 { [%eval 7,27] } 54...Rb3+
{ [%eval 0,30] } 55.Rc3 { [%eval 3,27] } 55...Rxb2 { [%eval 0,36] } 56.Rxb2
{ [%eval 3,27] } 56...Rxb2 { [%eval 0,44] } 1/2-1/2

I decided to end this little test with pushing the above further. The final pair of games were set to time controls of 30 seconds per move. This slowed the games down massively. It also handed two more victories to Stockfish.

[Event "Engine match"]
[Site "?"]
[Date "2014.07.06"]
[Round "6.1"]
[White "Deep HIARCS 14 WCSC"]
[Black "Stockfish 060714 64"]
[Result "0-1"]
[ECO "C25"]
[EventDate "2014.07.06"]
[OpeningBook "Online book: Tournament"]
[OutOfBook "From move 7."]
[TimeControl "m30000"]

1.e4 e5 { [%eval 24,24] } 2.Nc3 Nc6 { [%eval 12,24] } 3.g3 Bc5
{ [%eval -13,23] } 4.Bg2 d6 { [%eval -10,23] } 5.Na4 Bd4 { [%eval -10,23] }
6.Ne2 Nge7 { [%eval 1,25] } 7.c3 { [%eval -12,22] } 7...Bxf2+
{ [%eval 3,25] } 8.Kxf2 { [%eval -12,20] } 8...b5 { [%eval 3,26] } 9.d4
{ [%eval -26,21] } 9...O-O { [%eval 13,22] } 10.b4 { [%eval -28,19] }
10...bxa4 { [%eval -9,23] } 11.Qxa4 { [%eval -15,19] } 11...f5
{ [%eval -15,24] } 12.Re1 { [%eval 6,19] } 12...f4 { [%eval -13,23] } 13.gxf4
{ [%eval 35,18] } 13...exf4 { [%eval -19,24] } 14.Rf1 { [%eval 10,19] }
14...f3 { [%eval 0,23] } 15.Bxf3 { [%eval 33,20] } 15...Bg4 16.Nf4
{ [%eval 42,20] } 16...Bxf3 { [%eval -17,24] } 17.Kxf3 { [%eval 52,20] }
17...g5 { [%eval 0,25] } 18.Rg1 { [%eval 4,21] } 18...Nxd4+ { [%eval -6,25] }
19.cxd4 { [%eval 53,20] } 19...Ng6 { [%eval 0,24] } 20.Qb5 { [%eval 57,19] }
20...gxf4 { [%eval 0,26] } 21.Qh5 { [%eval 35,20] } 21...Qf6 { [%eval 0,27] }
22.Bb2 { [%eval 36,20] } 22...Rab8 { [%eval 23,27] } 23.Rac1
{ [%eval 50,19] } 23...Rf7 { [%eval 0,28] } 24.Ba1 { [%eval 7,21] } 24...d5
{ [%eval 0,30] } 25.Qxd5 { [%eval 39,19] } 25...Qh4 { [%eval 0,32] } 26.Qe6
{ [%eval 48,19] } 26...Kf8 { [%eval 0,28] } 27.Rc2 { [%eval 29,20] }
27...Qh5+ { [%eval 0,29] } 28.Qg4 { [%eval 62,20] } 28...Qb5 { [%eval 0,29] }
29.Rd1 { [%eval 45,20] } 29...Re8 { [%eval -71,22] } 30.e5 { [%eval 50,19] }
30...Rg7 { [%eval -46,23] } 31.Qf5+ { [%eval 47,19] } 31...Kg8
{ [%eval -5,24] } 32.Qe4 { [%eval 34,18] } 32...Qxb4 { [%eval -5,24] } 33.Qc6
{ [%eval 36,17] } 33...Qe7 { [%eval -3,24] } 34.Ke2 { [%eval 37,18] }
34...Qf7 { [%eval -6,24] } 35.Qc4 { [%eval 32,18] } 35...Re6 { [%eval 0,24] }
36.Kd2 { [%eval 33,18] } 36...c6 { [%eval 0,25] } 37.Rb2 { [%eval 23,19] }
37...Nf8 { [%eval 0,26] } 38.Rf1 { [%eval 43,18] } 38...Nd7 { [%eval 0,27] }
39.Qb3 { [%eval 0,19] } 39...Nb6 { [%eval -85,24] } 40.Kc1 { [%eval 0,21] }
40...Nd5 { [%eval -87,26] } 41.Rbf2 { [%eval -15,18] } 41...Re7
{ [%eval -75,25] } 42.Qd3 { [%eval -6,20] } 42...Rb7 { [%eval -56,25] }
43.Bb2 { [%eval -61,20] } 43...Nb4 { [%eval -138,26] } 44.Qe2
{ [%eval -85,22] } 44...Qf5 { [%eval -172,27] } 45.Qc4+ { [%eval -91,22] }
45...Kh8 { [%eval -177,28] } 46.Rd2 { [%eval -91,21] } 46...Nd5
{ [%eval -199,27] } 47.Qd3 { [%eval -112,21] } 47...Qxd3 { [%eval -218,28] }
48.Rxd3 { [%eval -117,20] } 48...Rg2 { [%eval -225,29] } 49.Rb3
{ [%eval -152,23] } 49...Rxb3 { [%eval -225,28] } 50.axb3 { [%eval -136,23] }
50...Kg7 { [%eval -231,27] } 51.Ba3 { [%eval -127,23] } 51...Kf7
{ [%eval -251,27] } 52.h4 { [%eval -190,24] } 52...Ke6 { [%eval -253,27] }
53.Re1 { [%eval -213,22] } 53...a5 { [%eval -337,26] } 54.h5
{ [%eval -352,24] } 54...Rg3 { [%eval -380,28] } 55.Kd2 { [%eval -477,24] }
55...Rxb3 { [%eval -455,31] } 56.Bc1 { [%eval -624,25] } 56...a4
{ [%eval -646,28] } 57.Kc2 { [%eval -790,25] } 57...Nb4+ { [%eval -836,28] }
58.Kd2 { [%eval -876,24] } 58...a3 { [%eval -913,30] } 59.Bxa3
{ [%eval -895,24] } 59...Rxa3 { [%eval -969,29] } 0-1

[Event "Engine match"]
[Site "?"]
[Date "2014.07.06"]
[Round "6.2"]
[White "Stockfish 060714 64"]
[Black "Deep HIARCS 14 WCSC"]
[Result "1-0"]
[ECO "E58"]
[EventDate "2014.07.06"]
[OpeningBook "Online book: Tournament"]
[OutOfBook "From move 18."]
[TimeControl "m30000"]

1.d4 { [%eval 20,23] } 1...Nf6 2.c4 { [%eval 25,23] } 2...e6 3.Nc3
{ [%eval 17,24] } 3...Bb4 4.e3 { [%eval 24,24] } 4...O-O 5.Bd3
{ [%eval 10,23] } 5...d5 6.Nf3 { [%eval 13,24] } 6...c5 7.O-O
{ [%eval 8,24] } 7...Nc6 8.a3 { [%eval 22,24] } 8...Bxc3 9.bxc3
{ [%eval 15,26] } 9...Qc7 10.Bb2 { [%eval 20,23] } 10...dxc4 11.Bxc4
{ [%eval 24,24] } 11...e5 12.h3 { [%eval 24,24] } 12...Bf5 13.Qe2
{ [%eval 24,23] } 13...Rfe8 14.Rfd1 { [%eval 39,21] } 14...e4 15.Nd2
{ [%eval 47,23] } 15...h6 16.Nb3 { [%eval 56,24] } 16...cxd4 17.cxd4
{ [%eval 63,24] } 17...Rac8 18.g4 { [%eval 57,23] } 18...Bg6
{ [%eval -14,20] } 19.Rac1 { [%eval 55,24] } 19...Qd6 { [%eval -15,19] }
20.Qf1 { [%eval 55,25] } 20...Red8 { [%eval -7,20] } 21.Rd2 { [%eval 49,25] }
21...Ne7 { [%eval -19,20] } 22.Rdc2 { [%eval 51,27] } 22...Ned5
{ [%eval 0,20] } 23.Nd2 { [%eval 57,26] } 23...Rc7 { [%eval 0,20] } 24.Bb3
{ [%eval 45,25] } 24...Rxc2 { [%eval 0,20] } 25.Bxc2 { [%eval 63,26] }
25...Qe6 { [%eval 0,22] } 26.Bb3 { [%eval 54,25] } 26...h5 { [%eval 0,21] }
27.g5 { [%eval 52,26] } 27...Nd7 { [%eval 16,21] } 28.Rc7 { [%eval 31,26] }
28...b5 { [%eval 0,22] } 29.Qg2 { [%eval 41,27] } 29...a6 { [%eval 0,22] }
30.Qg3 { [%eval 44,28] } 30...N7b6 31.Rc5 { [%eval 37,27] } 31...Na4
{ [%eval 15,19] } 32.Bxd5 { [%eval 113,29] } 32...Rxd5 { [%eval 142,25] }
33.Qb8+ { [%eval 141,29] } 33...Kh7 { [%eval 142,24] } 34.Rc8
{ [%eval 156,31] } 34...Rxg5+ { [%eval 144,24] } 35.Kh2 { [%eval 162,33] }
35...Kh6 { [%eval 141,24] } 36.Rh8+ { [%eval 162,32] } 36...Bh7
{ [%eval 127,22] } 37.Qf4 { [%eval 155,32] } 37...Kg6 { [%eval 135,25] }
38.Nxe4 { [%eval 163,32] } 38...Rf5 { [%eval 124,24] } 39.Qg3+
{ [%eval 169,31] } 39...Kh6 { [%eval 138,11] } 40.d5 { [%eval 165,29] }
40...Qg6 { [%eval 123,24] } 41.Nd6 { [%eval 177,29] } 41...Qxg3+
{ [%eval 144,23] } 42.Kxg3 { [%eval 178,30] } 42...h4+ 43.Kg2
{ [%eval 181,27] } 43...Rg5+ { [%eval 152,24] } 44.Kf1 { [%eval 181,29] }
44...Kg6 { [%eval 158,24] } 45.Bd4 { [%eval 184,29] } 45...Rxd5
{ [%eval 180,24] } 46.Nxf7 { [%eval 196,28] } 46...Kxf7 { [%eval 170,26] }
47.Rxh7 { [%eval 200,28] } 47...Kf8 { [%eval 170,25] } 48.Rxh4
{ [%eval 189,30] } 48...Nc5 { [%eval 177,25] } 49.Rh8+ { [%eval 195,29] }
49...Kf7 { [%eval 191,26] } 50.Ra8 { [%eval 204,29] } 50...Ne6
{ [%eval 189,25] } 51.Ra7+ { [%eval 204,28] } 51...Kg8 { [%eval 196,27] }
52.Bb2 { [%eval 209,28] } 52...Rd6 { [%eval 210,25] } 53.Ke2
{ [%eval 219,29] } 53...Rc6 { [%eval 203,25] } 54.Be5 { [%eval 219,30] }
54...g6 { [%eval 203,25] } 55.Kd3 { [%eval 205,29] } 55...Ng5
{ [%eval 210,24] } 56.f4 { [%eval 211,29] } 56...Nf3 { [%eval 210,24] }
57.Bg7 { [%eval 214,29] } 57...Re6 { [%eval 210,23] } 58.e4
{ [%eval 234,25] } 58...Rc6 { [%eval 234,22] } 59.Ke2 { [%eval 260,26] }
59...Ng1+ { [%eval 269,25] } 60.Ke3 { [%eval 281,27] } 60...Rc1
{ [%eval 257,23] } 61.Be5 { [%eval 306,27] } 61...Rb1 { [%eval 255,23] }
62.Rg7+ { [%eval 312,28] } 62...Kf8 { [%eval 313,23] } 63.Rxg6
{ [%eval 318,29] } 1-0

Running through these ought to give some indication of what sort of improvements the next generation of HIARCS software will need in order to retain its titles. On the plus side, compiling and running Stockfish to augment HIARCS in HCE is dead simple (though obviously it requires gcc, g++ and xcode).
Website: Organised Adversary - ICCF: 30667
OpenPGP/GPG Key: 0x321E4E2373590E5D - BTC address: 18Ua6y7D65QatEDZ36dtWNWpG9Ttrd4eqy
User avatar
Hasimir
Member
Posts: 62
Joined: Sun Jun 29, 2014 1:24 pm
Location: Australia
Contact:

Post by Hasimir »

Addendum: HIARCS fares a little better with a significantly boosted cache and hash table size. The previous games were at 256MB/64MB, that's been boosted to 1,024MB/512MB. Even so, it's still only breaking even.


[Event "Engine match"]
[Site "?"]
[Date "2014.07.07"]
[Round "7.1"]
[White "Deep HIARCS 14 WCSC"]
[Black "Stockfish 060714 64"]
[Result "1/2-1/2"]
[ECO "C24"]
[EventDate "2014.07.07"]
[Notes "Hash table and cache sizes vastly increased (to 1,024MB and 512MB, respectively)."]
[TimeControl "m5000"]

1.e4 e5 { [%eval 37,16] } 2.Bc4 Nf6 { [%eval 12,18] } 3.d3 c6
{ [%eval -3,19] } 4.Nf3 d5 { [%eval 7,19] } 5.Bb3 Bd6 { [%eval 7,20] } 6.exd5
cxd5 { [%eval 3,19] } 7.Bg5 Be6 { [%eval -14,19] } 8.Nc3 Bc7
{ [%eval -20,20] } 9.d4 e4 { [%eval 5,18] } 10.Nd2 Nc6 { [%eval 44,21] }
11.Bxf6 { [%eval 44,15] } 11...Qxf6 { [%eval 38,20] } 12.Bxd5
{ [%eval 52,16] } 12...O-O { [%eval 26,21] } 13.Ndxe4 { [%eval 48,17] }
13...Qg6 { [%eval 27,20] } 14.Ng3 { [%eval 47,16] } 14...Rad8
{ [%eval 45,19] } 15.Bxc6 { [%eval 70,17] } 15...bxc6 { [%eval 55,19] }
16.O-O { [%eval 67,17] } 16...f5 { [%eval 29,20] } 17.Qd3 { [%eval 48,15] }
17...Qh6 { [%eval 22,20] } 18.Rfe1 { [%eval 34,17] } 18...f4
{ [%eval 25,19] } 19.Nf1 { [%eval 44,18] } 19...Bb6 { [%eval 25,22] } 20.Qe2
{ [%eval 3,18] } 20...Bf7 { [%eval 17,21] } 21.Nd2 { [%eval 2,16] } 21...Bxd4
{ [%eval 31,22] } 22.Nf3 { [%eval 18,18] } 22...Bf6 { [%eval 24,21] } 23.Qa6
{ [%eval 28,16] } 23...Bxc3 { [%eval 36,21] } 24.bxc3 { [%eval 18,18] }
24...Bd5 { [%eval 21,22] } 25.Qd3 { [%eval 24,18] } 25...Qh5
{ [%eval 17,22] } 26.Rad1 { [%eval 30,17] } 26...h6 { [%eval 27,24] } 27.Qe2
{ [%eval 0,17] } 27...Rde8 { [%eval 0,25] } 28.Qd3 { [%eval 0,15] } 28...Rd8
29.Qe2 Rde8 { [%eval 0,26] } 30.Qd3 Rd8 1/2-1/2

[Event "Engine match"]
[Site "?"]
[Date "2014.07.07"]
[Round "7.2"]
[White "Stockfish 060714 64"]
[Black "Deep HIARCS 14 WCSC"]
[Result "1/2-1/2"]
[ECO "A45"]
[EventDate "2014.07.07"]
[Notes "Hash table and cache sizes vastly increased (to 1,024MB and 512MB, respectively)."]
[TimeControl "m5000"]

1.d4 { [%eval 24,20] } 1...Nf6 2.Bf4 { [%eval 20,19] } 2...d6 3.e3
{ [%eval 25,18] } 3...c5 4.Nd2 { [%eval 30,19] } 4...cxd4 { [%eval 17,15] }
5.exd4 { [%eval 11,18] } 5...Nc6 { [%eval 31,17] } 6.Ngf3 { [%eval 9,19] }
6...Bg4 { [%eval 28,16] } 7.h3 { [%eval 49,17] } 7...Bh5 { [%eval 28,16] }
8.c3 { [%eval 30,18] } 8...e5 { [%eval 17,16] } 9.Be3 { [%eval 22,20] }
9...Be7 { [%eval 3,15] } 10.Bd3 { [%eval 15,21] } 10...exd4 { [%eval 5,16] }
11.cxd4 { [%eval 21,21] } 11...O-O { [%eval -17,16] } 12.O-O
{ [%eval 18,20] } 12...Nb4 { [%eval -13,16] } 13.Bf5 { [%eval 20,19] }
13...Qa5 { [%eval -17,16] } 14.g4 { [%eval 27,21] } 14...Bg6
{ [%eval -28,15] } 15.Bxg6 { [%eval 19,21] } 15...fxg6 { [%eval -27,16] }
16.Qb3+ { [%eval 15,19] } 16...Nbd5 { [%eval -21,16] } 17.Bf4
{ [%eval 21,20] } 17...Qb4 { [%eval -50,16] } 18.Bg3 { [%eval -11,20] }
18...Qxb3 { [%eval -69,17] } 19.axb3 { [%eval -43,20] } 19...Nb4
{ [%eval -60,18] } 20.Kg2 { [%eval -29,23] } 20...b5 { [%eval -75,14] }
21.Nb1 { [%eval -24,17] } 21...Nc2 { [%eval -70,15] } 22.Ra5
{ [%eval -30,22] } 22...Nd5 { [%eval -39,19] } 23.Rc1 { [%eval -29,24] }
23...Rxf3 { [%eval -42,18] } 24.Kxf3 { [%eval -28,24] } 24...Nxd4+
{ [%eval -32,20] } 25.Kg2 { [%eval -46,24] } 25...Nxb3 { [%eval -38,19] }
26.Rxb5 { [%eval -40,24] } 26...Nxc1 { [%eval -39,20] } 27.Rxd5
{ [%eval -32,23] } 27...Rb8 { [%eval -39,19] } 28.Bxd6 { [%eval -29,23] }
28...Rd8 { [%eval -32,21] } 29.Rc5 { [%eval -30,24] } 29...Bxd6
{ [%eval -24,20] } 30.Rxc1 { [%eval -25,24] } 30...Rb8 { [%eval -23,20] }
31.Nd2 { [%eval -30,20] } 31...Bf4 32.Rc2 { [%eval -16,21] } 32...g5
{ [%eval -17,19] } 33.Ne4 { [%eval -8,24] } 33...h6 { [%eval -21,19] } 34.Nc5
{ [%eval -8,26] } 34...Bd6 { [%eval -17,21] } 35.Nd3 { [%eval -9,24] }
35...Rb3 { [%eval -14,21] } 36.Nc1 { [%eval -3,24] } 36...Rb5
{ [%eval -14,22] } 37.Kf3 { [%eval 0,25] } 37...a5 { [%eval -12,21] } 38.Nd3
{ [%eval -5,26] } 38...Be7 { [%eval -9,21] } 39.Rc4 { [%eval 0,28] } 39...Bf6
{ [%eval -6,20] } 40.Ra4 { [%eval 0,29] } 40...Kh7 { [%eval -6,22] } 41.b4
{ [%eval 0,28] } 41...axb4 { [%eval -6,22] } 42.Nxb4 { [%eval 0,28] }
42...Rb8 { [%eval -7,17] } 43.Nc2 { [%eval 0,28] } 43...Rb7
{ [%eval -13,19] } 44.Ne3 { [%eval 0,31] } 44...Rf7 { [%eval -13,19] } 45.Kg2
{ [%eval 0,28] } 45...Rd7 { [%eval -11,21] } 46.Ra6 { [%eval 0,29] } 46...Bc3
{ [%eval -10,22] } 47.Kf3 { [%eval 0,28] } 47...Rf7+ { [%eval -13,17] }
48.Ke2 { [%eval 0,28] } 48...Rb7 { [%eval -13,14] } 49.Kd3 { [%eval 0,19] }
49...Be5 { [%eval -11,19] } 50.Ke4 { [%eval 0,25] } 50...Bb8
{ [%eval -12,21] } 51.Nf5 { [%eval 0,27] } 51...Bc7 { [%eval -10,21] } 52.Ra4
{ [%eval 0,25] } 52...g6 { [%eval -7,20] } 53.Ne3 { [%eval 0,25] } 53...Bb6
{ [%eval -5,21] } 54.Kd3 { [%eval 0,29] } 54...Rf7 { [%eval -21,19] } 55.Ra6
{ [%eval 0,28] } 55...Ba7 { [%eval -21,22] } 56.Re6 { [%eval 0,28] } 56...Kg7
{ [%eval -21,21] } 57.Ra6 { [%eval 0,31] } 57...Rb7 { [%eval -21,21] } 58.Rc6
{ [%eval 0,29] } 58...Rd7+ { [%eval -21,22] } 59.Ke2 { [%eval 0,32] }
59...Re7 { [%eval -21,21] } 60.Ra6 { [%eval 0,32] } 60...Bd4
{ [%eval -20,21] } 61.Kd3 { [%eval 0,31] } 61...Rd7 { [%eval -19,21] } 62.Ke4
{ [%eval 0,29] } 62...Ba7 { [%eval -20,17] } 63.Kf3 { [%eval 0,29] } 63...Rc7
{ [%eval -18,19] } 64.Ke4 { [%eval 0,32] } 64...Rb7 { [%eval -18,22] } 65.Kd3
{ [%eval 0,30] } 65...Rd7+ { [%eval -18,20] } 66.Ke2 { [%eval 0,31] }
66...Re7 { [%eval -18,22] } 67.Ra5 { [%eval 0,34] } 67...Bb6
{ [%eval -18,21] } 68.Ra6 { [%eval 0,40] } 68...Bd4 69.Kd3 { [%eval 0,41] }
69...Rd7 70.Rc6 { [%eval 0,32] } 70...Ba7+ 71.Ke4 { [%eval 0,30] } 71...Rf7
{ [%eval -16,21] } 72.Ra6 { [%eval 0,31] } 72...Rb7 73.Kd5 { [%eval 0,29] }
73...Re7 { [%eval -18,20] } 74.Ra3 { [%eval 0,28] } 74...Kh7
{ [%eval -21,19] } 75.Kc6 { [%eval 0,27] } 75...Bb8 { [%eval -13,19] } 76.Nd5
{ [%eval 0,28] } 76...Rf7 { [%eval -11,21] } 77.f3 { [%eval 0,30] } 77...Kg7
{ [%eval -12,20] } 78.Rb3 { [%eval 0,30] } 78...Bh2 { [%eval -12,22] } 79.Ra3
{ [%eval 0,29] } 79...h5 { [%eval -12,21] } 80.Kc5 { [%eval 0,28] } 80...Rf8
81.Kd4 { [%eval 0,25] } 81...Bg1+ { [%eval -9,21] } 82.Ke4 { [%eval 0,26] }
82...Re8+ { [%eval -8,21] } 83.Kd3 { [%eval 0,27] } 83...Re5
{ [%eval -4,22] } 84.Kc4 { [%eval 0,25] } 84...Re1 { [%eval -9,19] } 85.gxh5
{ [%eval 0,24] } 85...gxh5 { [%eval -16,17] } 86.Nc3 { [%eval 0,25] }
86...Bh2 { [%eval -17,19] } 87.Ra5 { [%eval 0,24] } 87...Kg6
{ [%eval -24,19] } 88.Ne4 { [%eval 0,25] } 88...Bf4 { [%eval -19,20] }
89.Ra6+ { [%eval 0,26] } 89...Kf5 { [%eval -16,21] } 90.Rf6+ { [%eval 0,24] }
90...Ke5 { [%eval -20,10] } 91.Ra6 { [%eval 0,25] } 91...Rc1+
{ [%eval -21,17] } 92.Kd3 { [%eval 0,25] } 92...Rd1+ { [%eval -23,21] }
93.Ke2 { [%eval 0,24] } 93...Rd5 { [%eval -20,21] } 94.Ra7 { [%eval -6,25] }
94...h4 { [%eval -21,23] } 95.Ra4 { [%eval -6,27] } 95...Rb5
{ [%eval -22,23] } 96.Ra8 { [%eval -6,26] } 96...Kf5 { [%eval -31,21] }
97.Rf8+ { [%eval -6,26] } 97...Kg6 { [%eval -23,22] } 98.Ra8
{ [%eval -6,26] } 98...Rb6 { [%eval -35,21] } 99.Ra2 { [%eval 0,28] }
99...Kh5 { [%eval -23,23] } 100.Kd3 { [%eval 0,28] } 100...Rb3+
{ [%eval -22,22] } 101.Ke2 { [%eval 0,29] } 101...Rb5 { [%eval -22,23] }
102.Ra6 { [%eval 0,30] } 102...Be5 { [%eval -22,23] } 103.Ra8
{ [%eval 0,28] } 103...Rb2+ { [%eval -21,21] } 1/2-1/2
Website: Organised Adversary - ICCF: 30667
OpenPGP/GPG Key: 0x321E4E2373590E5D - BTC address: 18Ua6y7D65QatEDZ36dtWNWpG9Ttrd4eqy
Post Reply